D.R. Horton's sales center sits at the Model Home Park on Coastal Living Lane in Millville. The builder lists homes in Millville By the Sea from $379,990 and describes the community as 5 miles from Bethany Beach. A beach shuttle runs from the amenity hub, next to the pool, clubhouse and crab shack. Bethany Beach's own finance review for the fiscal year that ended March 31, 2026 counted 76 properties that changed hands in a taxable sale, at an average price of $1.3 million.
Those two numbers come from two different kinds of supply. In Bethany Beach, price follows how few homes come up for sale in a given year. In Millville, the reference point is a builder's price sheet. Approvals already on the books mean that price sheet will be competing with resale homes for years. If you're choosing between an in-town address and a newer home off Route 26 or Route 17, that difference matters more than the five miles. It affects how your home's value is likely to behave after you own it.
A town where few homes change hands each year
The Town of Bethany Beach's final FY2026 review says the average sale price rose 14% to $1.3 million in the fiscal year that ended March 31, 2026. Taxable transfers went from 62 the year before to 76. Transfer-tax revenue for that year came in $478,000 over budget and $421,000 above the prior year. The pace held into the current fiscal year. The town's FY2027 revenue report shows $600,583 in real estate transfer-tax receipts through July 31, 2026. At the same point the year before, receipts were $444,088.
Seventy-six sales is a small number for a beach town with this many visitors. When so few homes sell, an average reflects which particular houses happened to sell that year, so it shifts more than the underlying market does. The MLS figures for the wider Bethany area show the same thing on a monthly scale. That area covers the Bethany Beach, North Bethany and South Bethany postal cities. In October 2026 it had 24 sales at a $920,500 median. In October 2025 it had 23 sales at a $1,175,000 median. Over the full 12 months from November 2025 through October 2026, the median sale price rose 8.7%, to $995,000. When a few sales can swing a single month's median by more than $250,000, look at the 12-month figure before deciding what the market is doing.
Two more figures from those same 12 months help explain how the Bethany market behaves. About half the sales were cash, 106 of 209, and the median home sold in 15 days. As of November 4, 2026, there were 62 homes listed as Active or Coming Soon. At the past year's sales pace, that's about 3.6 months of supply. Short supply means a well-priced home doesn't wait long for a buyer.
For comparison, Bright MLS reports 5.31 months of supply across Sussex County in October 2026. The county had 2,461 active listings, up 11% from a year earlier. The county median sale price was $490,224, up 5.7%, and the median home took 40 days to sell, according to the Bright MLS October 2026 report. The county is building inventory faster than the beach towns.
Five miles inland, Millville keeps adding homes
At the Sept. 22 Millville Town Council meeting, the town's financial consultant, PFM Financial, presented the town's growth figures. Millville went from 658 homes in fiscal 2014 to 2,052 in fiscal 2024, an increase of 212%. Over the same decade, its median home value rose from $268,300 to $494,500, according to Coastal Point's report on the meeting. Home values in Millville rose a lot. The number of homes rose much faster.
More homes are coming. At its Tuesday, Feb. 10 meeting, the Millville Town Council approved 278 homes in two new sections of Millville By the Sea. Blue Heron Cove will have 19 single-family homes and 141 townhomes, and Sea Turtle Cove will have 118 townhomes, as Coastal Point reported. On Oct. 13, the council voted unanimously to annex nearly 95 acres off Burton Farm Road for Coastal Farm, a proposed Christopher Companies community next to the western edge of Millville By the Sea that could bring more than 300 new homes into the town, according to Coastal Point's report on the vote. The residential planned community zoning approved for the parcel requires a mix of housing types, with 40 percent single-family.
The builder's current price list shows where the market sits today. On D.R. Horton's Millville By the Sea page, the nine floor plans start in a range from the Brentwood in the $392s to the Wheaton in the $635s. West Bay Village, about a mile from the main entrance, lists homes from $324,990. Builder prices change often, so treat these as a snapshot. Anyone selling a resale home in Millville By the Sea is competing with that price list and with the model homes a short drive away. That's still true while approved sections are waiting to be built.
Coastal Point's report on the PFM presentation also said the town's real estate transfer-tax revenue helped grow its unassigned fund balance to $17.6 million at the end of fiscal 2025, up from $9.2 million at the end of fiscal 2022. PFM's consultant called that revenue "volatile." Both towns' budgets depend heavily on home sales, with Bethany's transfer-tax revenue coming from a small number of expensive resales and Millville's tied to how fast new homes are built and sold.
| Town of Bethany Beach | Millville | |
|---|---|---|
| Recent sales or growth | 76 taxable transfers in FY2026, which ended March 31, 2026 | Grew from 658 homes in FY2014 to 2,052 in FY2024, with 278 more approved Feb. 10 and Coastal Farm annexed Oct. 13 |
| Price figure | $1.3 million average sale price, FY2026 | D.R. Horton list from $379,990 at Millville By the Sea |
| What sets the price | How few homes come up for sale | New-home price lists nearby |
What the beach shuttle and the drive cost you
D.R. Horton lists the amenities at Millville By the Sea as a clubhouse, community pools, a fitness center, a crab shack, bocce, pickleball, walking trails, a fishing pond and a beach shuttle. In Bethany Beach, your house sits within the town's own walkable grid of streets. In Millville, the shuttle and the drive stand in for that walk. The neighborhood amenities are what you get in return.
The drive matters most in summer. Coastal Point reports that Millville has been hosting public discussions about traffic. The roads under study are Route 26, Old Mill Road, Club House Road and Irons Lane, and officials said the planning would focus on getting more out of existing roads, not building new ones. DelDOT officials said a traffic signal at White's Neck Road and Route 26 was in preliminary design for 2026 and 2027, with installation expected in fiscal 2029 under the funding schedule at the time, according to Coastal Point's coverage of the Millville Community Transportation Plan. If you're buying inland, plan on those summer drive times for at least the next few seasons.
The corridor is also getting more places to eat. The Cape Gazette reported that 1776 Steakhouse plans a 222-seat location at 30415 Cedar Neck Road in Ocean View, in the former Big Fish Grill, and is aiming to open in March 2027 after renovating over the winter.
How rental income figures into each choice
Many Bethany buyers count on rental income. The town's FY2026 review shows rental tax revenue came in $26,000 under budget and $38,000 below the prior year. The town's presentation said the state's new 4.5% rental tax, which took effect the year before, may have led fewer owners to rent out their properties. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm how any tax applies to your property with your own accountant or attorney.
That same year, the average sale price rose 14% and taxable transfers increased. So less rental activity didn't slow sale prices in town. That's consistent with a market where many buyers pay cash and few homes come up for sale. If you're comparing rental potential across property types in town, our earlier look at condos versus beach houses in Bethany covers that.
A few quick answers
Is the $1.3 million average still current? It covers the town's fiscal year that ended March 31, 2026. More recent town figures show transfer-tax receipts through July 31, 2026 running about $156,000 ahead of the same point a year earlier. For the past 12 months, the wider Bethany-area median was $995,000.
How far is Millville By the Sea from the beach? D.R. Horton's community page says 5 miles from Bethany Beach. Its general Millville description says 4 miles.
Which villages is D.R. Horton building in right now? The builder says it's selling in three villages: Belle Shoal, Turtle Cove and West Bay Village. Turtle Cove sits next to the main amenity hub.
If you're weighing an in-town Bethany address against a newer home off Route 26, I'm glad to go through recent sales on the specific streets and sections you're considering. If you already own a home in either town, a home valuation will show where your property stands in this market. You can find more on the town on our Bethany Beach neighborhood page. When you're ready to put the two side by side, reach out to Denise Karas. Let's Connect.